Mussels in an Herbed White Wine Sauce - Restaurant Worthy!

I co-hosted a dinner party a while back for our closest friends- most of us who have been together since college! We decided to make it super classy-- simple, decadent dishes and a wine pairing with each course. I was tasked with the appetizers and side dishes (he did the hard work - stuffed crown roast!). We wanted to push the envelope bit for our friends who much prefer mini hot dogs over escargot. :) I decided to make classic mussels in an herbed white wine sauce.

It turned out to be the best idea! I'm not kidding, this is better than dishes I've had in restaurants. Having never worked with mussels before, I did hours of research into cleaning, preparation and recipes and came up with the below recipe- an Elaine original! I hope you enjoy; this really is a fun, cheap and delicious alternative to standard dinner party fare.Even those initially wary loved it. Experiment!

 Ingredients

6 pounds fresh mussels (I used Prince Edward Island [P.E.I.] Mussels), scrubbed and beards removed
4 T olive oil
4 T butter (go ahead, use the whole stick if you want.)
8 shallots, finely chopped
8 garlic cloves, minced
32 oz. chicken stock
2 cups dry white wine
2 cups heavy cream 
8 T fresh herbs (I used an herb paste, but would recommend basil, parsley, thyme, maybe even a but of oregano or rosemary)
Good quality crusty bread, warmed right before serving
 
Directions  

Scrub and debeard (remove a thin hairlike strand) mussels. Throw away any that are opened. If mussels are slightly opened, tap on their shell. Good mussels should close; toss those that stay open. 

Preheat a very large pot (fair disclosure, I underestimated how large a pot I would need!) over high heat. Once pot is heated, add the butter and olive oil. Warm until butter melts.

Into the melted butter, add the shallots, with a pinch of salt and pepper. Stir until shallots are softened, about 5-7 minutes. Add the garlic and cook until fragrant, about 1 minute or just slightly longer.


Add wine, chicken stock and the mussels into the pot. Cover with a lid and steam until all mussels open, about 12 minutes. Discard any mussels that do not open. 

Remove the mussels with a slotted spoon and place into a large serving bowl. (Remember to set an extra bowl on the table for the shells.) To the remaining liquid, add the cream and herbs (or herb paste) and adjust seasonings with salt and pepper. Once you have a great-tasting broth, pour over the mussels in the bow.

Serve with warm, crusty bread and soak in the complements.